Q: Is there any tradition in Shia sources in which it has been reported that Lady Fatima Zahra (S.A) picked up a quarrel with the Commander of the Faithful, Ali (A.S). If it is mentioned in any Shia sources, then kindly let me the sources and the narrators as well as our Shia scholars’ opinion about it? A: Assalamu alaykum , This story has been fabricated by Sunni narrators and some of our books have just quoted them. They say that Ali (A.S) proposed to marry the daughter of Abu Jahl (may Allah curse him), which angered Fatima (A.S.). This story is false in both the original and secondary sources, and we have conducted a thorough research into it.